« Bargain of the Day: tentacle warmer | Main | Everyone say 'Aww.....' »

December 20, 2005

Pennsylvania Judge Boots ID Out

by Red Wolf

In a delightful example of common sense, Judge John Jones of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania ruled that intelligent design — which bills itself as a scientific theory and states that life shows signs of being the work of an intelligent designer — is in fact reworked creationism.

The decision comes after 11 parents sued the Dover High School Board of Education for requiring that biology students be read a statement that cast doubt on evolution and endorsed intelligent design. Eight of the nine school board members were voted out of office in November, but the case continued in the court.

In his decision, Jones systematically dismantled the arguments of the proponents of intelligent design. Jones said that the history of intelligent design shows that it is essentially creationism with explicit references to God and the Bible removed. As such, it is primarily a religious theory, not a scientific one, and cannot be taught in US public schools, which are prevented from promoting religion.

Jones also said that language in the school board statement that evolution is only a theory is misleading. It confuses the scientific and colloquial meanings of theory. And by singling out evolution from all other scientific theories it suggests that there is some special doubt about the truth of evolution.

The judge stated that intelligent design cannot be considered science for a number of reasons. By depending on a supernatural cause it violates the basic ground rules of science that have been in place since the 16th century.

He also found that intelligent design relies on the false dualism that if evolution can be disproven, then intelligent design is proven. In any case, he found that intelligent design's criticisms of evolution have been largely refuted.

I'm deeply amused by the wingnuts who are pimping intelligent design as a valid scientific theory, when past attacks on the theory of evolution have been over their misunderstood use of the word theory in the first place. Perhaps this whole mess could have been avoided if somebody just handed the idiots a dictionary. Oh, that's right, they aren't permitted to think or learn for themselves.

Judge rules against 'intelligent design' in classNew Scientist, 20th December 2005.

Tags: , ,

Posted in Rare Common Sense and Science Fiction at 23:58. Last modified on September 28 2006 at 23:43.
| View blog reactions

Comments

1: Posted by: G. TIngey | December 21, 2005 8:51 AM

This is really, really important.
" ... he (The Judge)came right out and said that the creationist side lied - and lied repeatedly."

This must be repeated, in public, in all countries (not just the USA - we've got creationist lying nutters here in GB as well ...)

Excuse me for shouting, but I feel I must celebrate, but if ANYONE AT ALL starts talking about ID or creationism, the shout must be , in public, as loud and as frequently as possible.
LIAR - YOU ARE A DELIBERATE PUBLIC LIAR - SUE, OR SHUT UP!

Incidentally, can we now do this to the author of "The politically incorrect guide to science" one Tom Bethell?

Please, please, please?

2: Posted by: Feòrag | December 21, 2005 3:11 PM

Ed at Dispatches from the Culture Wars has put a copy of the full (139 page!) decision up at his web site: Case No. 04cv2688, Memorandum Opinion.

Wax lyrical

Evangelism, witnessing and similar activitites go by one name here—advertising, and is no different from spam for viagra, penis enlargement products and pornography. We do not take advertising. If you want to advertise your imaginary friend, please spend your own money on your own web space to do so. Any attempts to use the comments section for advertisements will be deleted, and the perpetrator barred, unless they are particularly stupid, in which case I reserve the right to pinch an idea from Teresa Nielsen Hayden and delete all the vowels.

This is not a contacts site. If you are looking for help regarding a particular path, I suggest The Witches' Voice, which does operate a contacts service.

Allowed HTML: a href, b, br, p, strong, em, ol, ul, li, blockquote, q, pre. If your name has accents in it, things will work better if you use the XHTML entities for those letters. The same applies if you are using a word processor to compose your comment, then copying and pasting the text—either turn off curly quotes and avoid using em-dashes, or edit your comment after pasting to get rid of them. Garbled comments usually get deleted.






You must give one to comment, but it will not be displayed and we won't let the spammers have it. If it is obviously false, your comment will be deleted, except in extenuating circumstances.







You must preview your comment first. Blame the spammers.